
This model unit focuses on teachers and students developing a contextual drama. The model unit provided is a case study of how one drama was structured. Teachers and students will choose their own topics for exploration.
1992 marked the 500th anniversary of Columbus' arrival in America.
As part of their Social Studies
course students in this grade
eight class were required to
write a term essay on the current
event of their choice and to
present their work orally. The
essay and oral presentation of
one the students was entitled
"Columbus 500" (a term which the
teacher later learned had been
borrowed from the theme of the
December 1991 issue of The
Internationalist magazine,
the major source used by the
student in researching this
topic). This particular oral
presentation generated a lengthy
class discussion. Most students
readily agreed that Columbus
hadn't "discovered" America --
they understood that the Vikings
had been there centuries before.
Only a few of the students had
accepted that the "discovery of
America" was a purely Euro-
centric view of history, a view
that did not recognize the
perspectives, rights or even the
humanity of the Aboriginal
peoples who already lived there.
None of the students, except the
one whose report inspired the
discussion, understood that the
Columbus "discovery" proved to be
a harbinger of the colonization
and exploitation of land and
people that would extend over the
next five hundred years and
beyond.(Note)
Choosing the Topic
Following the discussion in the Social Studies class, the teacher (who also teaches drama to these students) wonders how she might structure a drama that would prompt the students to further acknowledge and understand the validity of views other than the traditional view of the Columbus story. She does not intend that the students attempt a re-enactment of the Columbus landing or that they work in role as Tainos(Note) and Spaniards. Rather, she would like to structure a dramatic situation that provides some parallels to history and could, in part, be interpreted as an allegory for those events.(Note) As the students are currently rehearsing a collective about cars which they are scheduled to perform just before the Easter break, the teacher has some time to research and plan this work. When she next meets the students for Social Studies, she tells them the class discussion that followed the presentation of the "Columbus 500" report has been on her mind. She asks whether they would consider pursuing some of the ideas that emerged from that discussion in their next drama. She says she realizes they will not be ready to begin another drama for a couple of weeks but she wanted to get their approval of the topic before she put any work into it. One student asks if this means they will actually be doing a drama about Columbus. The teacher says possibly, but that the Columbus landing may simply be the inspiration for the work. The students' response, while not wildly enthusiastic, is positive. The teacher thanks them and says she will begin work on it.
(Note)
Working Within the
Drama
The students will:
Teacher in Role/Storytelling/Talking Circle -- Whole Group
The class begins with the teacher and students sitting on the floor in a circle.(Note) The teacher reminds the students that they had agreed to do a drama based on Columbus' landing in the Americas. She says that while they may not immediately recognize it as a drama about Columbus' landing, they will be able to draw parallels between the events in the drama and the historical events as the work unfolds. She says if they are ready she will leave the circle and when she returns to her place she will return in role. She reminds them that as the first episode of the drama unfolds, they should be able to identify a role for themselves within the work. She leaves the circle.(Note) The teacher returns to the circle wearing a shawl around her shoulders and carrying a small stick.(Note) She sits, places the stick on the floor in front of her and welcomes the group by saying that once again they are gathered to discuss plans for their Harvest Celebration.(Note) She says that as she grows older, it seems as if the time from one harvest to the next grows shorter and that, as is their tradition, this gathering will begin with the story....
(Note) "Long ago, before the Cold Time, the world was filled with people. There were large magical cities full of light and the sounds of many machines made of metal. A person had only to push buttons and work was done by machines. Machines even flew, like great birds, through the sky. People did not work in the fields. People got their food in boxes of many shapes and sizes from special places in the cities. Life was easy, there was plenty for all. Then came the Cold Time. It was said that a great rock fell from the sky. Dust and clouds filled the air and the sun could not shine for many years. Snow fell even in summer and covered the earth. Crops did not grow. Soon there was no food and everywhere there was death. But all did not die. Our ancestors hid in this valley. They suffered great hardships but they survived the Cold Time. When the Cold Time ended the world was not the same. Now we are the only people and we live in this valley as our ancestors did. The land is good again. We grow crops, herd our animals and raise our families. After each harvest we gather to celebrate the abundance of the earth and to give thanks."
(Note)
When the story is
finished the
teacher in role tells the group
that it is now time to pass the
talking stick.(Note)
She asks them to
think back for a moment on the
time which has passed since the
last harvest and to decide what
it is that they have been most
grateful for during that time.
She offers to begin. She takes
the stick and says that since
the last harvest she has become
a grandmother once more. She
says the baby was quite ill but
is now healthy and it is for
this that she is grateful. She
passes the stick to the student
on her left who says that he is
grateful for the abundant rains
that have enabled them to
produce healthy crops. The
stick continues around the
circle. The students who wish
to speak do so as they receive
the stick. They speak about
fine gardens, the birth of
triplets, the building of a
woodworking shop, a good berry
season, the finding of a
medicinal herb which seems to
hasten the recovery of minor
wounds, and the recovery of some
useful metals from the ruins at
the south end of the valley.
Before the stick has reached the
hands of the last couple of
students in the circle, the
gathering is interrupted by the
entrance of an excited person
who announces that, as they
know, she and two others have
been away for a few days herding
the sheep. She says they have
come back sooner and rather more
hurriedly than expected because
of an extremely unusual
occurrence. She says she and
the others have discovered a
person wandering in an area
close to where the sheep were
grazing. The person is not one
of them. He wears unfamiliar
clothing, speaks in a way that
is difficult to understand and
seems to be quite weak. She
says she was sent ahead to
prepare them and very soon the
others will bring him into their
midst. (Note)
This announcement is met
by a barrage of questions: Are
you sure? How can it be that
there is a person who is not one
of us? Will they be here soon?
etc.(Note)
The teacher out of role
Reflection Out of Role -- Whole Group
The students will:
The students enter the room for their next drama class somewhat expectantly, as if, perhaps, to find something or someone out of the ordinary. They ask the teacher whether "the person" will be part of the drama today. The teacher begs their patience and asks them to be seated. She asks them to please cast their minds back to the previous class and to describe what they were thinking as the class came to a close. One student says the opening episode was quite interesting. He says the story told by the old woman provided the drama with a strong setting and the surprise ending to the class made him want to know what would happen next. One of the girls says she was amazed at how the images of the place grew as each of them contributed an idea when they were handed the stick. Another student says there was a lonely feeling to it. She says it is hard to imagine that the only people who would exist anywhere would be the people in one's own community or group. Another says that she was able to believe that and so when the announcement came that a stranger had been found, she felt a sense of foreboding, a sort of fear.(Note) One of the boys says that something about all of this reminds him of a science fiction movie he recently saw abut a group of survivors after a nuclear war.(Note) Another asked what any of this has to do with Columbus? The teacher asks him to patient and suggests everyone keep this question in mind.
She says that what they have to say about the work so far is intriguing and she asks them to please move the desks aside now and to sit where they were in the circle in the previous class. She says they will recall that as the last class drew to a close, the gathering of those who had assembled to plan harvest celebrations was interrupted. She says to resume the drama they will "rewind the tape" a bit and begin with the entrance of the messenger. She asks whether there are any questions or comments. Satisfied that there are none, she dons her shawl and joins the circle in her place.(Note) The two volunteers who had participated in the drama toward the end of the previous class leave the room and join the "messenger", who is again waiting in the hall. Guest in Role/Teacher and Students in Role/Hot Seat -- Whole Group
The students will:
The teacher offers the stick to
the last person who spoke and,
on cue, the messenger arrives
and makes her announcement. As
the questions erupt from the
group, the two volunteers in
role as the companions described
by the messenger enter,
supporting a man between them.(Note)
The man who seems
weak and a
little uneasy wears clothing
unlike any the valley dwellers
have ever known (a colourful
costume reminiscent of those
seen in contemporary science
fiction movies). Around his
waist he wears a wide belt from
which hangs a slender metal
cylinder. On one end of the
cylinder is a clear smooth disc.
The messenger moves into the
centre of the circle and spreads
a loosely woven blanket on the
floor. She takes her place in
the circle. Her companions
guide "the person" to the
blanket, help him to become
comfortably settled by
cushioning his head with a
couple of rolled-up sweaters and
return to their places in the
circle.(Note)
The teacher in role
As this episode of
As they leave the old woman turns to the group and says she believes it is important that they try to understand what it is they have heard. She asks the students in role what they have learned. Together, the valley dwellers and the old woman encapsulate what they have heard and understood from the stranger. From having this man in their midst they have learned that there are other people in the world who may not be living very far away. They know these people do not live in their valley and from what they have learned from Lance Surveyor, they know these others live in a place that is not very like their valley. Lance Surveyor spoke of "The Great Dome". He said that to live there means that one does not live under the sky. He said he was not certain that people could live under the sky; he thought they needed a dome to protect them from the sun and the wind, the rain and the snow. He said he believed his weakness was caused by his being too long away from "The Great Dome", that the "unfiltered" air in the valley was like a poison to his body. He said he was in need of food and asked whether the valley people could spare a "food bar". He spoke of men and women called "mandarins" who own everything and make decisions for others. He spoke of "police" who ensure that these decisions are followed by everyone. He was surprised to learn that the valley dwellers do not know about such things; that their land and other things that they have as they go about their work and lives belong to all of them; that valley dwellers make decisions together and need no one to ensure that they live by those decisions. They were surprised when he warmed his hands with the warm light which came from the tool which hung around his waist. They had not imagined such tools. They learned that "The Great Dome" is "over crowded" and that he and others have been sent out on large machines in search of land on which to build another. If he had not become separated from his people and stumbled weakly into the valley, the valley people would not know that they shared the world with others. When no further ideas are expressed, the teacher in role asks: "What is it that we must do now? What will we do with Lance Surveyor?"
The bell rings as the teacher in role approaches the end of her statement. Quickly she asks the students to consider those two questions before the next class. What should the valley dwellers do about Lance Surveyor and how should they respond to their new knowledge about "The Great Dome" and its inhabitants. As the students are going out the door, one of them asks whether they will get to talk to the person who worked in role as Lance again. The teacher says yes.
Reflection Out of Role -- Whole Group
The students will:
When the students arrive for their next drama class, both the teacher and the person who worked as Lance Surveyor are waiting for them. The teacher introduces "Lance" as her friend. She tells the students that, in real life, he is a farmer from a neighbouring town. She says both of them are involved in the same community theatre group which is centred in a town about sixty-five kilometres away. She says he has agreed to sit in on this class to learn what they are thinking about the progress of their drama and also to share with them his thinking about the unique experience which he had enjoyed with them in the previous class.
The teacher says that, ideally, they would have had the opportunity to discuss the experience when it was freshest but as usual the work went longer than expected and they were cut off by the bell. She asks them to think back to the last period and their personal response to Lance and to the interview that ensued. The students generally agree that to have a real life stranger in the drama not only added to the tension in the work but for some reason it really seemed to make them believe more in their own roles and generally made them more committed to the drama. Maybe, one of them suggests, that was because they had some one new to act for! One of the students says he thinks he has spent more time thinking about what happened in that particular episode of the drama than he has about any other single part of any drama he has ever done. He goes on to say that he thinks the valley dwellers are in real trouble. The way he sees it the dome dwellers are a serious threat whichever way you look at it. If the dome dwellers realize the valley dwellers are there, they are probably doomed. Clearly, he says, the dome dwellers are more technologically advanced and if the "flashlight" is any indication, they probably have enough laser weapons to obliterate everyone in the valley.(Note) He says he supposes they could persuade Lance Surveyor to stay or, failing that, they could hold him so that he couldn't return to "The Great Dome" and divulge the existence of the valley and its people. But even if Lance didn't get back, he believes its only a matter of time before someone else or many someones stumble into the valley.
Another student says that her view is a more optimistic one. She says that it sounds to her as if things are not all going well in "The Great Dome". If the dome dwellers have been there as long as the valley dwellers have been in their valley, they probably don't know anything about life outside a dome. In fact, according to what little they know from Lance Surveyor, it may be that this generation of dome dwellers would be unable to survive outside the dome. In either case, it makes sense to her that co-operation and a sharing of knowledge, skills and goods that would benefit both communities would be the best course of action for all concerned.
Another student says that, while they might believe that a spirit of co-operation would be best, it doesn't seem to him to be the way things would work between two groups when one of them is clearly more powerful than the other. In this case, he would have to agree with the boy that spoke first. The valley dwellers couldn't win, if it came to a fight. They would either all be wiped out or captured and put to work as slaves or something like that. Perhaps, another student offers, the valley dwellers should move on. They have the skills they need to survive in the natural environment and they could begin a community somewhere else. As well, she says, now that we know the valley dwellers are not the only people on the earth, it is quite likely that there would be other groups and the valley dwellers could well come across other people whose life styles are similar to theirs.
As the discussion continues, other students seem generally to side with one of the views that has been expressed. The teacher says she is very pleased with their ideas and, as the drama continues, they will work with all of them. Now she says they are probably interested in what their guest thinks of all of this. "Lance" says that when their teacher invited him to come and participate in a "drama", he really didn't realize what he was getting himself into. He says he has been in a number of plays and has done improvisational work in auditions and rehearsals, but he had never been called upon to think on his feet for such a sustained period before. He says the class made it relatively easy for him because they believed in the Lance role and, even when they came up with questions that he hadn't anticipated, he found the answers rolling off his tongue. He says probably the most challenging aspect of it all for him was to make sure that he consistently spoke in the formal way that he did. He said he agreed with their teacher that his way of speaking was important if they were all to sustain their belief in the Lance role and in the situation. It helped, he said, that not all of what Lance said was meant to be understood by the valley dwellers, and because Lance was a little weak, he was able to speak more slowly and deliberately. He tells the students that he was really impressed by their response to him in role during the previous class.(Note) He says he had not expected to have to work in the Lance role for the whole period. He tells them that, as he listened to the discussion earlier in this period, he was again impressed by their ideas and how they connect what they know and feel about the real world to a purely fictional situation. He says he wished he had had drama classes like this when he was a student.
The time remaining in the period
is taken up by an informal
discussion in which the guest
and the teacher respond to
students questions about their
work in community theatre. They
talk about why they became
involved, how long they've been
participating, why they think
people in rural areas attend
their plays, how people of all
ages can become involved and on
and on. As the bell rings, the
students and their guest thank
and applaud one another.(Note)
The Grade Eight Model Unit
Continues
