
Chemistry involves the study of the composition, structure, and properties of matter and its reactions. During this unit, the emphasis should be on directly observing a wide variety of chemicals and their reactions. Encourage the students to identify patterns and trends in their findings, and search for generalizations that emerge from their investigations.
Limit the depth of study of this unit. Writing chemical equations and depicting the configurations of atoms in molecules are topics which should not be covered. Do not attempt, through lectures or detailed explanantions, to impart to students principles beyond those which they are able to observe through activities and in their experiences. Turning science at the Middle Level into an abstract set of principles and theories divorced from what can be observed gives students an inappropriate view of science.
The suggestions given for activities in this unit are the means by which important concepts are developed. Terminology and mathematical relationships should be used to describe concepts which have already been encountered and clarified in the students' minds, rather than memorized in order to be able to describe what they see.
Many of the activities suggested in this unit involve the use of readily available household substances. Teachers who do not have a background in chemistry may wish to consult with Secondary Level chemistry teachers regarding some other chemical reactions which might be investigated in this unit. Chemical reagents and special apparatus for performing some other chemical reactions might have to be obtained from a high school chemistry lab.
Safety precautions are important when performing
investigations involving chemical reactions. Teachers should be
alert to such considerations at all times.
In this unit as in all others, two additional emphases are important. Science writing and reading, as discussed in this Guide, should be incorporated into each lesson. Writing in personal, reflective journals, reading from newspapers, and reporting science activities in a variety of ways are only three strategies through which students may refine their understanding of the concepts of science and develop their ability to communicate through the written word.
Science challenge, as described in this Guide, is meant to extend students' critical and creative thinking abilities in the context of the science concepts being studied. The challenge is intended to give each student a chance to investigate an area of interest in more depth than would be possible for all students in a class to do. Science challenge is a key strategy for bringing the Adaptive Dimension to the classroom, and for encouraging independent learning.
Note: Emphasize safety precautions whenever chemicals are used. The chemicals should never be handled with bare hands or tasted. Safety glasses or goggles should be worn. (Various reference materials on laboratory safety are available. Consult these to familiarize yourself with important aspects of safety.)
Many of the resources listed in Science: An Information Bulletin for the Middle Level - Key Resource Correlations describe activities or ideas for activities.
Ask each student group to place a variety of
substances
in
water and observe how they behave. Remind them to record all
observations
.
(Note: Always add the substances to water. Not only does
this aid mixing of powders but it
may be an important safety precaution. Some acids react
violently when water is added to them, but
when they are added to water, since they are more dense than
water, they mix more easily.)
Some examples of things they might add to the water include:
candle wax, steel wool, rubbing alcohol,
laundry soap, vinegar, baking soda, corn starch, flour, sugar,
paint thinner (use this in a well ventilated
area), Alka Seltzerþ tablets, cooking oil, salt crystals, Tangþ
crystals. Most of these are commonly
available household substances.
Emphasize safety precautions whenever chemicals are
used.
After each substance has been tested, the container used for
testing should be rinsed out thoroughly
before the next test. Proper disposal methods should be used for
each of the substances tested. The
disposal method varies, depending on the substance used. For
example, the candle wax should not be
poured down the drain, but can be placed in ordinary waste
containers. A guide for disposal of
chemicals, A Guide to Laboratory Safety and Chemical
Management in School Science Activities,
is available from Saskatchewan Environment and Public Safety in
Regina.
Once all of the substances have been tested, students should
discuss which tests might have involved a
chemical reaction. A class discussion could be held as part of
the follow-up to reach a consensus on
those conclusions. During the discussion, students should be
prepared to support their opinions,
indicating what things were observed which lead them to believe
that chemical changes had or had not
taken place in each test.
In many cases, the difference between a chemical reaction and a
physical change is not obvious. In
these instances, a distinction between these two different types
of phenomena need not be made.
Ensure that both girls and boys are encouraged to be involved in
these activities.
Factors: A1, A4, B1,
B2, B9,
B13, C3,
C6, C9,
C11, C12,
E3, G1
Objectives: 3.1, 3.2,
3.3, 5.1
Assessment Techniques: observation checklists, rating
scales, assessment stations, written
assignments
Instructional Methods: cooperative learning groups,
inquiry
Repeat, mixing egg whites and water. Shake well. Observe,
record, and compare with the control. Try
using egg yolks and water. Compare this with the results
obtained using egg whites.
Repeat, adding some liquid detergent to an oil and water
mixture. Shake and observe. Repeat again,
adding egg white to the oil and water mixture. Compare all
results.
Factors: A4, B1, B2,
B9, B10,
C3, C6,
C9, C11, C12, E3,
G1
The tests can be repeated using crayon, pencil, or marking pen
impressions on the paper towel. For
each test performed, students should observe the way the liquid
interacts with the mark on the paper
towel. Evidence which indicates that a chemical reaction might
have occurred should be noted.
A colour change in this activity does not necessarily indicate
that a chemical change has taken place.
Different substances may be migrating at different rates through
the paper. This is similar to what
happens in paper chromatography. Dilution may also be
responsible for the change in colour.
Factors: A4, B1, B2,
B9, B10,
C3, C6,
C12, E3, G1
Obtain a small sample of phenolphthalein indicator. A little bit
goes a long way. It can be obtained from
a chemistry lab. Ex-laxþ is another source. Add Ex-lax to water
and filter to obtain a phenolphthalein
solution.
Use a fountain pen or pen nibs to write with the phenolphthalein
solution on a sheet of paper. Allow
the liquid to dry. Mist the sheet of paper with an ammonia
solution from an atomizer. The indicator
will turn pink in a basic solution.
Take four samples of steel wool. Soak two in alcohol. Remove the
samples and allow them to dry. Place
one original and one alcohol-soaked sample in separate
containers of water. Repeat with the other two
samples, using salt water. Label all containers. Have students
predict what will happen to each
sample.
Allow all samples to remain in the water for three days. Observe
and compare the results. Make
generalizations about the factors that contribute to the
corrosion of iron.
Twin with a Secondary Level class. Arrange to have students in
the senior class take slides of evidence
of corrosion in the community. They can receive credit for their
projects based on criteria established by
their teacher at the Secondary Level. Use the slides to observe
how metals corrode. Make some
generalizations about things that contribute to the corrosion of
metals.
Repeat, replacing epsom salts with alum. Add vinegar to the
precipitate. Evaporate and compare the
product to the powder produced when an alum solution is allowed
to evaporate.
Hang a weighted string in the salt solutions. As evaporation
occurs, top up by adding more saturated
salt solution. Once the crystals have grown for several weeks,
remove and dry them. Observe them
carefully with a hand magnifier. Draw the shape of the crystals.
Have students discuss the
observations.
Add some baking soda to hot water and dissolve. Pour the mixture
into an aluminum tray. Put a
tarnished piece of silverware into the tray and let it stand for
about an hour. Remove the silverware,
rinse with tap water, and dry it. Compare it to another
tarnished piece of silverware which did not
receive this treatment.
Many commercial processes involve chemical reactions. Products
can be purchased for cleaning copper
and removing tarnish from silver. Most of these products have
been developed using an understanding
of chemistry. The products have important applications in our
lives.
This activity takes some of the mystery out of how these
products work. It also helps to show students
that inexpensive alternatives can sometimes be found to replace
expensive products which essentially
do the same thing. This helps to develop a sense of consumer
awareness to help the environment.
Pour about 30 mL of vinegar into a pop bottle.
Put some baking powder in a balloon. Tap the baking
powder so that it goes down to the bottom of the balloon.
Fit the opening of the balloon over the mouth of the pop bottle.
Lift the balloon and shake the contents
into the pop bottle. When the baking powder and the vinegar mix,
a chemical reaction takes place. Gas
is released. The balloon expands. Do this on a mass balance to
show that mass is conserved during a
chemical reaction.
Limewater (saturated calcium hydroxide solution, available from
a chemistry lab) can be used to test
the gas. Remove the balloon without allowing the gas to escape.
Place a straw over the end of the
balloon. Then place the straw in the limewater to allow the
carbon dioxide gas from the balloon to mix
with the limewater. Limewater turns cloudy in the presence of
carbon dioxide gas.
Using a straw, exhale into the limewater. Where does the carbon
dioxide in the exhaled breath come
from? (Extend this into Health, discussing human
respiration.)
Collect samples of chemical elements. Some
should be easy to
find - copper, iron, aluminum - and
others more difficult. Some periodic tables have pictures of the
elements. One such item is #60451 from
Have each group of students select one of the elements to
research. They should try to find out: its
symbol; when it was discovered; the name of the scientist who
first discovered or identified it; the
physical and chemical properties of the element; the uses of the
element; the names of other elements
that have similar chemical properties.
Groups could prepare a poster summarizing the results of their
findings or report their findings in a
story or poem, a song, or an interview with a group member
playing the part of the element.
Have the entire class attempt to develop a classification scheme
for the elements that have been
investigated, based on their physical and chemical properties.
Because only a small number of elements
were researched, the classification extension of this activity
is analogous to early attempts at classifying
elements based on their periodicity.
The public nature of science is revealed through the activity.
Many scientific findings have been
published in a variety of resources and are available for people
to use. Everyone benefits when scientific
information is disclosed in this way.
Correlate this activity with the display of the table of
elements at the Saskatchewan Science Centre in
Regina.
Develop the connection of the symbols used and the elements they
represent. Explain that some
symbols are used to simplify notation. Write down the names of
a few chemical compounds. Show how
symbols are used to represent them. Establish that using symbols
makes it easier for people to
communicate in written form. To reinforce this, show how two
4-digit numbers would be expressed in
Arabic and Roman numerals. (Some methods for expressing things
in written form are more
cumbersome to use than others.)
Write the chemical equation for this underneath the
sentence:
Compare the written description of the chemical reaction with
its symbolic description as a chemical
equation. Note: To demonstrate this chemical reaction in
class, obtain a small piece of
magnesium ribbon. Hold one end of the magnesium ribbon with
metal tongs. Light the free end of the
ribbon. A bright flame will result. The magnesium ribbon will
change to a fine white powder.
Caution: This reaction produces heat. If the burning
magnesium falls, it could severely
burn anything it touches. Perform this demonstration over a
protective mat.
Science relies heavily on the use of symbols and symbolic
representations in order to convey
information. Chemical and mathematical equations are common
examples. Browsing through an
advanced science textbook reveals the use of a wide variety of
other symbols. Without the use of these
symbols, communicating scientific information in written form
would be very awkward and time-
consuming.
Repeat a second time, using a glass of cold water and a glass of
hot water. Simultaneously drop a sugar
cube in each. Observe and record all changes that take place.
Discuss the differences between how the
sugar cube behaves in cold water and in hot water. Have students
make inferences about why the sugar
cube behaves differently depending on the temperature of the
water.
This activity helps to reinforce ideas about how molecules
behave. The rate at which the sugar cube
dissolves can also be related to collisions. The average water
molecule is moving more rapidly in hot
water than in cold water. This allows the sugar cube to dissolve
faster in hot water. The fact that water
and sugar "combine" easily implies the existence of attractive
forces between them.
Some students may find that recording all observations in this
activity is tedious. So many different
things are happening, and it is not easy to record these events
descriptively. Emphasize the importance
of careful recording. Certain observations should not be
dismissed as being less significant than others.
One never knows which observations may turn out to be the
critical ones in a scientific investigation.
Working in groups, have students perform experiments in order to
try to develop and test an hypothesis
about what might be inside each container. The first test they
do would serve to establish an
hypothesis. Predictions can then be made about how the can might
behave when subjected to another
test. The second and any subsequent tests help to refine or
replace that hypothesis, based on the new
evidence. If the predictions are an accurate reflection of what
takes place, then the initial hypothesis
has been further substantiated.
Some examples of the types of tests that they might decide to
use could be: shake the can; tip the can
upside down; roll the can down an inclined plane; roll the can
along the floor. Emphasize that all of the
tests should be nondestructive -- that is, the containers cannot
be opened or damaged when tests are
performed on them.
Make sure that each group gets to test all of the numbered
containers. Once this has been done, hold a
"symposium," at which representatives from each group present
their findings. See if consensus can be
reached regarding the most likely contents of each can. Whether
or not consensus is reached, have
students discuss what they have learned about how investigations
are carried out, and how results are
shared.
Discuss the use of nondestructive observation in science. There
are many examples that can be used to
illustrate this. The use of exploratory techniques in medicine,
such as ultrasound, x-rays, CAT scans, or
fibrescopes, serve as good illustrations. Emphasize some of the
reasons why the need exists for
nondestructive testing.
Beneath the pendulum-magnet, place a few disk magnets in an
irregular pattern on the floor. Cover
those magnets with a piece of cloth or a large piece of paper.
With the students watching, swing the pendulum back and release
it. Observe the motion of the
pendulum. See if they can suggest what is causing the pendulum
to behave erratically. If they are able
to propose that other magnets under the cloth or paper might be
causing the interaction, have them
consider the system further to determine if similar or opposite
magnetic poles are influencing the
motion of the magnet.
This is an example of making inferences about unseen objects and
forces from observations. Similar
inferences must be made about atoms, since although we can't see
them, we make assumptions about
where they are and how they act based on chemical reactions.
Objectives: 1.2, 1.3, 3.1, 3.2
Assessment Techniques: anecdotal records, self and peer
evaluation, assessment stations
Instructional Methods: conducting experiments, problem
solving
Objectives: 1.3, 3.1,
3.3, 5.2
Assessment Techniques: observation checklists, rating
scales, oral tests, written reports
Instructional Methods: conducting experiments,
discussion
Boreal Laboratories
1820 Mattawa Avenue
Mississauga, ON
L4X 1K6
Write the following descriptive sentence down on the
blackboard:
Magnesium metal reacts with oxygen
gas to produce
magnesium oxide and
heat.
2Mg + O2 ---> 2MgO
+
heat
