
Often, the view that something is worth saving if it has economic or aesthetic value to humans is expressed. An example is "Rainforests should be saved because we haven't explored them completely yet, and there may be many valuable drugs or interesting creatures yet to be discovered." Rainforests should be preserved because they are a part of the system in which life has developed, and we anticipate that removing part of the system will have a negative effect on the whole system. Humans are an important component of the ecosphere but do we have a legitimate claim to primacy in the system?
In addition to developing an understanding of what the ecosystem is, students must become directly involved in helping to restore and protect it. Whether it be by cleaning up litter around the school, developing a recycling project, or writing to politicians about environmental issues, action to help improve the environment is essential or nothing, in effect, has been learned. What will drive this action is a love of the land. Love of the land is best developed out on the land. If students can be given opportunities to develop such a love during this unit, the understanding and action will follow.
In this core unit as in all others, two additional emphases are important.
Science writing and reading, as
discussed in this Guide, should be incorporated into each lesson. Writing plays
or skits, recipes for restoration or preservation, or drawing cartoons are only
three strategies through which students may refine their understanding of the
concepts of science and develop their ability to communicate through the written
(and illustrated) word. Readings from newspapers (Earthwatch, for example),
popular magazines, and science journals abound. Students can use these as models
for their writing style and as comparisons for their developing view of nature
and the world.
Science challenge, as described
in this Guide, is meant
to extend students
' critical
and creative thinking abilities
in the context of the science concepts being studied. The challenge is intended
to give each student a chance to investigate an area of interest in more depth
than would be possible for all students in a class to do. Science challenge
is a key strategy for bringing the Adaptive Dimension to the classroom, and
for encouraging independent learning. The topic of ecosystems offers possibly
the widest choice and interest to students for finding and carrying out independent
or small group investigations.
.
Note: Many of the resources listed in Science: An Information Bulletin for the Middle Level - Key Resource Correlations describe activities or ideas for activities.
The Earth can be viewed as a spaceship or a space colony. Life on Earth is interrelated in much the same way. Any changes invariably have an effect on a variety of living things. Complex patterns of dependence exist. Changes in one ecosystem influence other ecosystems. Ultimately, the study of changes that take place in an ecosystem should consider the larger, global implications of those changes.
Factors: A3, B2, B4, B12, D4, F1, F4, F6, G1
Objectives: 1.1, 1.2, 2.4, 2.5, 2.6, 3.1, 3.3, 5.2
Assessment Techniques: contracts, self- and peer-assessments, written assignments
Instructional Methods: simulations, brainstorming
Energy transformations and food webs in the ecosystems should be examined.
How do the abiotic factors within the ecosystem enable life to be sustained?
If the ecosystem changes with time, students might consider how the change
has affected life within the ecosystem.
Factors: A3, B2, B4, B13, C3, E2, F4, G1
Objectives:, 1.2, 1.4, 2.3, 2.5,
3.3
Assessment Techniques: anecdotal records, observation checklists,
group evaluations
Instructional Methods: model building, discussion
The students might need to establish criteria for what constitutes a grass
"plant." They might consider that each stem emerging from the ground represents
a single plant, even though grass sends out underground stems through vegetative
reproduction.
Calculate the total area of the lawn. Estimate the total number of grass
plants in the lawn. Have the students establish a method for determining
this. (Divide the total area of the lawn by the area used in making each
count. Multiply the result by the number of plants in the counted area.
Make any necessary adjustments to the calculations to account for such things
as bare spots on the lawn, competing vegetation growing on the lawn, or
sparse growth in some places on the lawn.)
Discuss the idea that some estimates have more credibility than others.
Estimates should always be more than just "wild guesses." They must be reasonable.
Are the results reasonable? Consider any assumptions that have been made
in arriving at the estimate.
Consider the variety of plant species within a given area. Does a larger
variety indicate a healthier ecosystem? Consider why bare spots exist. Are
they indicative of a healthy ecosystem?
This procedure can be used to estimate populations such as trees in a
forest, wildflowers or weeds in a field, plants in a field crop, and so
on.
Assessment Techniques: rating scales, homework, short answer test
items
Instructional Methods: problem solving, field observations
Crop specialists or extension agrologists could be interviewed on methods
of crop rotation.
For successful group work, all students must contribute to the group effort.
Encourage students to share and rotate the responsibilities for the required
tasks, such as investigating, observing, recording, and reporting.
Magnifying glasses, small garden tools for digging, scissors, tweezers,
assorted jars and containers with lids, shoe boxes, and plastic bags are
some things that students might use in this activity. While the investigation
is taking place, students can collect samples for further investigation
in the classroom.
Students should record the kind and number of each organism they find
in their plot. Any indirect evidence of life, such as animal droppings or
burrows, should also be noted. Students should try to determine if organic
matter on the ground came from plants within the plot or was transported
in from elsewhere. Dig up some of the soil in the plot and examine it for
any further evidence of animal life. Emphasize the need for the careful
recording of what has been observed.
Relationships and interactions among biotic and abiotic factors in their
study plot should be examined carefully. Abiotic factors which help to support
life should be noted.
Teachers may wish to assist students in developing organizers for their
observations, to provide more structure to this learning experience. If
so, here are some categories that students might consider.
Other ways of organizing the observations are encouraged. Before the actual
study is conducted, students could plan learning activities in collaboration
with their peers and with the teacher.
Using estimating techniques similar to those in the previous activity,
students can measure the area of a much larger section of the field and
estimate the number of a particular kind of living organism that might be
found there.
Caution students about things like broken glass, insect bites, bee stings,
and poison plants that they might experience in the area they survey.
Interrelationships between living and nonliving things in the environment
are very complex. We are only just beginning to appreciate some of those
complexities. One thing, however, is virtually certain. If people do not
act quickly to protect the environment, the destruction that would otherwise
occur could have a devastating impact. All life forms on Earth could be
threatened, including the human race. By developing an awareness of nature's
beauty, students may begin to value its preservation.
Students must develop an awareness that all forms of life need to be protected.
Humans have the responsibility for preserving the environment.
Endangered species can, in many cases, be saved if people act quickly
and
responsibly. All things are interrelated. A change in one ecosystem, however
small that change might be perceived to be, may have serious global consequences.
Remove one of the animals once the food chain has been constructed. Consider
how other animals in the ecosystem would be affected.
Imagine that the population of one of the animals in the ecosystem suddenly
increased dramatically. Identify what changes might occur as a result.
Simulate human encroachment in the ecosystem. Imagine that some of the
habitats are destroyed, or various types of pollutants are introduced. Consider
the implications that these types of changes would have on living things
within the ecosystem. Research actual case studies involving these changes.
The intricacy of the connections, graphically illustrated with the string,
gives students a better understanding of the complexity of biotic interrelationships
within an ecosystem. By introducing a change into the ecosystem, students
can begin to recognize what types of responses would occur.
See if you can establish the criteria that were used in selecting the
site. Was it in close proximity to a populated area? Were there abiotic
factors which influenced the selection of the site? Was the decision to
use the site based primarily on economic or political factors? These are
interesting things to research prior to the trip. Try to obtain newspaper
articles describing a recent decision regarding the placement of a landfill
site.
Examine the natural ecosystem within a short walking distance from the
landfill site. Record some of the living things that thrive in that location.
At the landfill site, see what living things exist. How have the conditions
changed to make it a preferable site for some life forms, but a less desirable
site for others? What other changes might take place over time at this site?
Perhaps the class could visit a very old landfill site which is now being
used for some other purpose.
Classify the type of waste found at the site. What resources went into
the production of the materials? How much energy was consumed in making,
using, and disposing of the materials? How are materials sorted on the site?
Which materials could be reused, recycled, reduced, or recovered? Which
of the materials are biodegradable and non-biodegradable? Which materials
might potentially leach into ground water? Which materials are potentially
toxic? (Keep this in mind in planning the trip. Some materials may need
to be identified beforehand as being hazardous, in order to not expose students
to any potential harm. Establish clear guidelines with the class.)
What are some of the less obvious consequences of landfill? Are there
any long-term global consequences that students might be able to identify?
What are the alternatives? Are they any better or worse? Research "accidents"
that have occurred at landfill sites, such as tire fires or explosions.
Landfill sites are not places that one would normally plan to visit --
unless, of course, one were interested in photographing seagulls! They are
intentionally located so as not to become too objectionable or the subject
of political controversy. It is worthwhile to visit a site like this occasionally,
if only to serve as a reminder of the impact that humans have on the environment.
Farms are special environments within ecosystems. Farming results in a
change in the way in which living things interact within the ecosystem.
Examine life forms on the farm from this perspective. Determine how living
things have either had to adapt or had to move as a result of the cultivation
of land. Consider interviewing an older farmer to reflect on the changes
that have taken place in agriculture over the years.
Investigate ways in which farmers are trying to protect natural ecosystems.
Determine how interdependence develops in cultivated and natural areas.
In what ways is the protection of natural ecosystems an advantage?
Have students speculate on when the farm was abandoned and what some of
the reasons were for the abandonment. This could either take the form of
an archaeological dig, or students could research the history of the farm
in local archives or by talking to neighbouring farmers.
The students could re-create what the farm might have originally looked
like, in a model or a drawing. A creative writing exercise could be a short
story about a fictional character on the farm.
Compare the cost per hectare of the land as it might have been fifty years
ago and now.
Be sure to ask the owner's permission to explore and investigate the property.
Find out about any possible dangers on the premises.
Try to divide the litter into two piles: one for all of the litter that
could have been likely produced by students, and another for the most likely
litter made by other people. From the two piles, they will be able to get
some idea of what their contribution to the damage in the environment has
been. They might want to speculate on what effect the litter might have
on living things. For further impact, leave the litter in the room for several
hours, to give students a lasting impression of how unsightly and smelly
it can be. This activity is one which could be a school project, getting
everyone involved in caring for the environment.
Consider ways in which litter affects living things. What are some of
its long-term consequences? What are some of its other implications, such
as the reduced potential for tourism?
A project like this helps to develop a better understanding of conservation
and care for the environment. Use it as a way to get students and other
members in the community interested in starting things like recycling projects.
By examining changes that have taken place over a longer period of time
Ä one or two generations at least Ä students will begin to appreciate that
long-term changes in an ecosystem may cause it to take on very different
characteristics.
Customary courtesies should be extended to Métis and Indian Elders.
Offer transportation if they accept an invitation to visit the classroom.
Arrange to provide gifts in exchange for information or service. Emphasis
should be placed on sharing. During oral communication, students should
ask a question and allow pause time for the question to be reflected upon
before an answer is given. Permission to record an interview should be obtained
beforehand. Other courtesies that are normally offered to any visitor to
the school should be extended.
Students can use this experience to further their understanding of ecosystems.
It serves as a good model of how larger, more complex ecosystems function.